Recent Posts:

---

What To Do If the CRA Says You Owe Money (But You Don’t Think You Do)

---

Should You Incorporate Your Business? Pros, Cons, and Costs

---

Late Tax Filings: How to Get Caught Up (Without the Panic)

---

How to Reconcile Your Bank and Credit Card Accounts Without the Stress

---

How to Fix an Incorrect Tax Return: Steps to Amend Your Filing

---

Estate Taxes 101: What Executors Need to Know Before Filing

---

Why Did My Tax Refund Get Delayed? The Top CRA Issues to Watch For

---

How to Protect Yourself from Tax Scams and Fake Calls

---

SMALL BUSINESS BUILDER

---

---

View AllSubscribe

Should You Incorporate Your Business? Pros, Cons, and Costs

It’s the most common question we hear from new entrepreneurs and growing freelancers: “Should I incorporate my business?”

Usually, the question is prompted by a friend at a dinner party who said, “You have to incorporate to save on taxes!” Or maybe you just landed a big contract, and the client prefers to work with a corporation rather than a sole proprietor.

Whatever the reason, deciding whether to incorporate is one of the most significant financial and legal decisions you will make for your business. It changes how you are taxed, how you are paid, and how you are legally protected.

At Padgett Business Services, we help business owners navigate this exact decision. There is no one-size-fits-all answer. This guide will break down the pros, cons, and costs of incorporating in Canada so you can make an informed choice.

What Does It Mean to Incorporate?

When you operate as a sole proprietor, you and your business are the exact same legal entity. If the business earns a dollar, you earn a dollar. If the business gets sued, you get sued.

When you incorporate, you create a brand new, separate legal entity. The corporation is essentially a “person” in the eyes of the law. It can own property, open bank accounts, sign contracts, and be sued. You are no longer the business; you are a shareholder and an employee of the corporation.

The Pros of Incorporating

1. Limited Liability Protection

This is often the primary reason people incorporate. Because the corporation is a separate legal entity, your personal assets (your house, your car, your personal savings) are generally protected from the debts and liabilities of the business.

If the corporation goes bankrupt or is sued, the creditors can only go after the corporation’s assets, not yours. (Note: There are exceptions, such as if you personally guarantee a business loan or act negligently as a director).

2. Lower Corporate Tax Rates

This is the benefit everyone talks about. In Canada, the small business tax rate is significantly lower than the top personal tax rates.

If your corporation qualifies for the Small Business Deduction (SBD), the first $500,000 of active business income is taxed at a very low combined federal/provincial rate (often between 9% and 12%, depending on your province).

3. Tax Deferral (The Real Tax Advantage)

Here is the catch with the lower corporate tax rate: it only benefits you if you leave the money inside the corporation.

If your business earns $150,000, but you need all $150,000 to pay your personal living expenses, incorporating won’t save you much tax. You will have to pull that money out as salary or dividends, and you will pay personal tax on it.

However, if your business earns $150,000 and you only need $70,000 to live on, you can leave the remaining $80,000 inside the corporation. That $80,000 is taxed at the low corporate rate, allowing you to defer the higher personal taxes until you withdraw the money years later (perhaps in retirement when your tax bracket is lower).

4. Easier Access to Capital

Investors and banks generally prefer to lend money to or invest in corporations rather than sole proprietorships. A corporation can issue shares to raise equity, which a sole proprietor cannot do.

The Cons of Incorporating

1. Increased Complexity and Paperwork

Running a corporation requires significantly more administrative work. You must maintain a separate corporate bank account. You must keep a corporate minute book. You have to file an annual return with the corporate registry.

2. Double the Tax Returns

As a sole proprietor, you file one tax return (your personal T1). When you incorporate, you must file your personal T1 and a corporate T2 tax return. Corporate tax returns are highly complex and almost always require a professional accountant.

3. Trapped Losses

In the early years of a business, it’s common to lose money. If you are a sole proprietor, you can use those business losses to offset your other personal income (like a salary from a day job), resulting in a tax refund.

If you are incorporated, the losses belong to the corporation. They are “trapped” inside the company and can only be used to offset the corporation’s future profits.

The Costs of Incorporating

Incorporating is not free, and maintaining a corporation costs money every year.

• Initial Setup Costs: Registering the corporation, doing a Nuans name search, and setting up the minute book will cost anywhere from $200 (if you do it yourself online) to $1,500+ (if you use a lawyer).
• Annual Accounting Fees: Because corporate tax returns and financial statements are complex, expect your accounting fees to increase significantly. Corporate year-end accounting typically starts around $1,500 to $2,500 per year and goes up from there.
• Annual Filing Fees: You must pay a small fee (usually under $100) to file an annual return with the government registry to keep the corporation active.

When Is the Right Time to Incorporate?

As a general rule of thumb, you should strongly consider incorporating when:

1. Your business is generating more profit than you need for your personal living expenses, allowing you to leave money in the corporation for tax deferral.
2. Your business carries a high risk of liability (e.g., construction, consulting on high-stakes projects), and you need to protect your personal assets.
3. You are planning to bring on investors or sell the business in the future.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Should I incorporate federally or provincially?

A: If you plan to operate strictly within one province, provincial incorporation is usually sufficient and slightly cheaper. If you plan to open physical offices in multiple provinces or want stronger protection for your business name across Canada, federal incorporation is better.

Q: Can I incorporate later if I start as a sole proprietor?

A: Yes! Many successful businesses start as sole proprietorships to keep costs low and utilize early losses. You can always transfer your sole proprietorship assets into a new corporation later using a “Section 85 rollover” to avoid triggering taxes on the transfer.

Q: How do I pay myself from a corporation?

A: You have two main options: you can pay yourself a salary (which requires setting up payroll and remitting CPP/taxes) or you can pay yourself dividends (which are paid out of the corporation’s after-tax profits). An accountant can help you determine the best mix for your situation.

Make the Right Choice for Your Business

Deciding to incorporate is a big step. Don’t make the decision based on what a friend did or what you read on a forum. Your business is unique, and your corporate structure should be tailored to your specific financial goals.

At Padgett Business Services, our business advisory experts can analyze your revenue, your personal cash flow needs, and your liability risks to determine if incorporating makes financial sense for you. If it does, we can guide you through the setup process and handle all your ongoing corporate tax needs.

Ready to take your business to the next level? Contact us today for a consultation.

The post Should You Incorporate Your Business? Pros, Cons, and Costs appeared first on Padgett Business Services | Canada.